Reply #9 - October 04, 2008, 07:06:09 PM
The edit does look good. The skin tone and everything. However, I think the makeup is overdone. I definitely touch up makeup in my shots. I do darken lashes and contour the face a touch if it needs it, and perhaps add a very very subtle touch of color to cheeks and lips, however, I usually don't add makeup especially colors that weren't originally there.
HOWEVER, it is up to your client and how much creative license you are expected to have. I wouldn't go changing things just because I thought they looked better if they are something the client will have a definite opinion about.
On the left eye (her right eye) the purple is a little too far into the inside corner of the crease (toward her nose), makeup artists don't put non-neutral color that far unless it is for a theatrical effect.
I sound negative, but I don't mean to. The color going too far to the center was my only nitpick the other stuff was just discussing ethics, and that's everyone's individual choice.

Logged